MILITARY ORDER OF THE LOYAL LEGION OF THE UNITED STATES

Loyal Legion Vignettes


AUGUSTUS PLUMMER DAVIS
FATHER AND FOUNDER OF THE
SONS OF UNION VETERANS OF THE CIVIL WAR

By
Richard D. Orr
Member, Pennsylvania Commandery, Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the U.S.
Past Commander-in-Chief, Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War
153 Connie Drive
Pittsburgh, PA 15214-1251
suvcworr@aol.com
(July 1999)


Augustus Plummer Davis
May 10, 1835 - May 21, 1899

As the membership of the Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War has grown in recent years, it has become apparent that the knowledge of the history of our Order is little known among a growing segment of our members. On May 21, 1999, we will commemorate the 100th anniversary of the death of our founder Augustus Plummer Davis who was affectionately know as "Father Davis." These have been the impetus for the completion of this biography of Augustus Plummer Davis, which was initiated by my father.

Augustus Plummer Davis, son of Anthony and Mary Davis, was born into a family of distinguished American patriots on May 10, 1835 in the little town of Gardiner, Maine. The Davis family came to the New World from Wales in 1670 and settled in Massachusetts, soon becoming active in local politics.

In 1730, Isaac Davis, great-great grandfather of A. P. Davis, was born on the family farm outside of Acton, Massachusetts. His son, Jacob, was born on the same farm in 1760. Both of these men were avid supporters of American independence and possessed an unrelenting distaste for British soldiers. The Acton Militia elected Issac Captain. Jacob also served in the same militia.

Early on the morning of April 19, 1775, Isaac received word that the British were moving towards Concord. He called out the Acton Militia. Under Captain Davis, these Minutemen rushed to Concord where they took a position in the center of the line at the North Bridge. Lead by Captain Davis, the Acton Militia were the first onto the bridge. One man preceded Captain Davis. He fell wounded. Captain Davis was immediately struck by a British bullet and was mortally wounded -- the first American casualty of the War for Independence.

Jacob followed in his father's footsteps and distinguished himself throughout the Revolutionary war. During 1785, Jacob Davis II, son of Jacob, was born in Maine. Jacob, grandfather of Augustus, answered his countries call and served in the War of 1812 as the Captain of his company. In private life, he devoted his efforts to local politics and the family farm. His son, Anthony G. Davis, was born in 1810 in Gardiner, Maine. He married Mary H. Plummer.

Augustus P. Davis had an uneventful early life. Being an adventurous lad, in 1849 at the age of 14, he took a job as a sailor on a freighter bound for San Francisco and the California gold rush. Once in California he remained there for about a year. With less han spectacular success in the gold fields and a strong calling to the sea, he once again took to the oceans in 1850. For the next five years he sailed the seas as a deckhand on various freighters. Always intrigued with military life, Davis combined it with his love of the sea and volunteered for service in the English Navy when the Crimean War erupted. For the next four years he served on man-o-wars. At the conclusion of his service with the Royal Navy he returned to the United States and promptly joined the United States Navy. He mustered out of the Navy in 1860 as a Petty Officer and returned to the family farm in Gardiner, Maine.

Within a few months Fort Sumter was besieged by the South Carolina militia. Answering his Nation's call as had his ancestors, on May 12, 1861 at the age of 26, Augustus volunteered for duty with the 11th Maine Infantry. He was immediately elected Captain of Company F. Davis and his company trained in Maine, then moved to Washington. Upon arrival in Washington, DC, the Regiment was assigned to General Casey's Division, Army of the James. The 11th Maine continued to train throughout the fall of 1861 and went into winter camp in Alexandria, Virginia.

On April 6, 1862, Captain Davis was unexpectedly detached from Company F, 11th Maine Infantry and permanently detailed as Provost Marshall of Casey's Division. The Division soon became involved in the Peninsular Campaign. On May 31, 1862, Augustus was wounded in his left side and left leg at the Battle of Fair Oaks, Virginia. He spent the next several weeks at a field hospital. In the fall of 1862, he returned to the Division near Suffolk, Virginia. Plagued by ill health he tendered his resignation on February 4, 1863. The resignation was accompanied by a surgeon certificate dated the same day and signed by Dr. D. W. Hand, Surgeon and Medical Director Peck's Division. It states ...he has tubercular deposits in the right lung, with pleuritic adhesions on that side. In consequence, I believe the exposure incident to field service will very soon assuredly break down his health.

In Special Order 7, paragraph 8, Department of Virginia dated February 7, 1863, A. P. Davis' resignation was officially accepted. However, it is clear that he did not follow through with the resignation. For upon returning to Maine, he was appointed Provost Marshall of the 3rd District of Maine. Affidavits in his pension file confirm this service and his military records show his actual discharge date as August 15, 1865.

Davis was appointed to brevet Major in the Volunteer forces to be effective March 13, 1865 by General Order 65, War Department, dated June 22, 1867. Following the War, Davis worked the family farm near Gardiner, Maine and served as a timekeeper at a nearby quarry on Dix Island.

In 1866, Augustus married Mary Ann Gilpatrick. They had one son, Herbert Anthony Davis, born January 27, 1868 at Dix Island, Maine. Unexpectedly, Mary Ann died on March 11, 1872 at Dix Island. Her death raised many suspicions. These were exacerbated when Davis married Lizzie E. Parks only three months later. Mary Ann is buried in Gardiner, Maine.

Davis' health had continued to decline and immediately after his marriage to Lizzie, moved the family to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. His doctor had advised him to move to a drier climate. Pittsburgh, not noted for being a dry climate, was an unusual choice and only added to the rumors surrounding Mary Ann's death.

At Pittsburgh, Davis established himself in the insurance business, primarily providing insurance services to manufacturing concerns.

A year after their arrival in Pittsburgh, Charles K. Davis was born. Charles eventually moved to Estes, Colorado and is buried there.

Augustus and Lizzie had a tumultuous relationship. Eventually Augustus sued Lizzie for divorce. The divorce was finalized on June 9, 1876, by the Court of Common Pleas in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. The divorce was exceptionally hard on the two boys. Lizzie was given custody of Charles and Herbert remained with Augustus, as Lizzie was not his natural mother. It is interesting that while A. P. Davis sued Lizzie for divorce on grounds of infidelity, on June 22, 1876, a scant two weeks later, he married Nancy E. Fulton.

Still suffering the effects of his maladies from the War, A. P. Davis filed a pension application #102297 on September 28, 1869. Initially, the pension was granted. However, on June 5, 1876, the pension was suspended when a number of complaints were received from residents of Gardiner, Maine. A number of individuals from Maine came forth and submitted sworn statements that Davis had a respiratory affliction since early childhood and his mother had died of consumption.

The War Department and Interior Department launched an investigation into the allegations of ineligibility for his pension. Supporting documents in the pension file only speak of Augustus medical conditions and not the other allegations. H. M. Plaisted, Member of Congress, late Colonel of the 11th Maine Volunteers, in his affidavit states that he believes that Davis acquired his illness as a result of his service during the Civil War.

In his statement to the Pension Board, dated December 27, 1876, A. P. Davis explains at length how he contracted his illness while in the service and vehemently denies he had any related illness as a child.

Other statements alleging misdeeds were filed with the Pension Board. In his sworn statement, James E. Webb characterized Davis as ...a man of ungovernable passion, vindictive, wicked in his temperament, most abusive and quarrelsome, and did not hesitate to brutally abuse his wife and his own father. Webb further states that ...Davis bears an unenviable reputation amongst the people of Kennebec, and in the opinion of the affiant all statements, or allegations, made by him shouldbe closely scrutinized.

In another affidavit, Joseph Williams echos the same sentiment, ...Davis was a man of ungovernable temper, vindictive, and vicious in his whole temperament. This Affiant further says from his best information that Davis was in the habit of whipping and brutally abusing not only his wife, but his father and grandfather.

For the record, it should be noted that neither A. P. Davis or any other individual ever disputed the allegations of abuse. While the veracity of these statements cannot be verified, it is very clear that A. P. Davis was not well-liked in his home town. The pension was eventually reinstated on March 9, 1886 with payments retroactive to February 22, 1877.

As he continued to press his case for a pension, Augustus built a life for himself, Nancy and Herbert in Pittsburgh. His insurance business flourished and as the business grew so did Augustus' social status. His membership in the Grand Army of the Republic (GAR) provided him with numerous business and social contacts. Alexander Hays Post 3, GAR was dominated by the captains of industry, political leaders, judges, lawyers and doctors. Its members included every Judge of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, the Mayor of Pittsburgh, all of the County Commissioners, state legislators and senators, Congressmen and names such as Negley, Neville, Craig, Hays, Melon and a plethora of other important Pittsburgh families. The rejected applicants included Andrew Carnegie who had been ruled ineligible for membership. Carnegie had been responsible for the design, construction, implementation and command of the Union telegraph system and was under the direct control of the Signal Corps. The Pennsylvania Department Commander relying on rulings of Commanders-in-Chief ruled he was a civilian employee of the War Department even though he possessed a discharge and was thus not eligible for membership.

Davis was active in other Civil War related veterans organizations. He was a member of the GAR, the Society of the Army of the James and the Society of the Army of the Potomac. He was one of the founding members of the Union Veteran League and a member of the Union Veteran Union. On January 14, 1880, he was elected to the Pennsylvania Commandery, Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States, Class I, Insignia Number 1981. He was one of the first members of the Fort Pitt Chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution. Davis was also a member of the Knights of Pythias and several Masonic Orders.

In July 1877, Davis made his first proposal for an organization of sons of GAR members. The proposal was resoundingly rejected by the members of Post 3. Over the next four years, Davis made at least three additional attempts to gain approval of the members of Post 3 to organize their sons. A young boys drum and bugle corps was actually begun only to be rejected by the Post members. Finally in September 1881, the Post 3 members took a neutral position on Augustus' latest proposal. They would not endorse his plan, nor would they oppose it.

David had devised a plan to organize the sons of members of the GAR into a military style organization whose purposes would mimic those of the GAR and additionally be bound to provide assistance to the members of the GAR. Membership was limited to the eldest living son of a GAR member.

The first organization meeting was held November 12, 1881 in the GAR Post 3 meeting room, 3rd floor of the Old City Hall. A group of eight boys meet and adopted the constitution, rules, regulations, and ritual written by A. P. Davis and formed the Sons of Veterans of Pennsylvania. They elected officers and thus was born the organization today known as the Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War.

Articles of Incorporation were filed on December 28, 1881, and approved by the Court of Common Pleas the same day. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania approved the charter on January 12, 1882.

Augustus fervently devoted his time, energy and money to the proliferation of the Sons of Veterans of Pennsylvania. Camps were formed throughout Pennsylvania, Eastern Ohio, Northern West Virginia and Southern New York. By mid year it was apparent that there was a need for a formal organization within Pennsylvania. On July 4, 1882, the Division of Pennsylvania was created and the first Division Encampment held in Pittsburgh.

Throughout the summer of 1882, the organization grew geometrically. By fall, there was a pressing need for a National Organization. On October 18, 1882, the first National Encampment was held in Pittsburgh. The constitution, rules and regulations proposed by A. P. Davis were adopted and the name of the corporation changed to Sons of Veterans of the United States of America.

A. P. Davis' grandiose vision of organizing the sons of veterans had become a reality. But the scope of his plan went far beyond simply organizing the sons. His plan is encapsulated in his own words.

For all his devotion to the Sons of Veterans, USA, Augustus P. Davis was declared a Past Commander-in-Chief and Past Grand Division Commander in August 1884. He was given the following letter to be deposited with the Camp of his choice.

On April 9, 1885, A. P. Davis deposited his membership with Davis Camp * and was entered upon the rolls.

Final and complete acceptance by the GAR came in 1888. In his report to the National Encampment of the GAR, Commander-in-Chief John P. Rea stated, It will be but a short period until our ranks are so meager and the surviving Comrades so weighed down with the burden of years that our organization will have ceased to be an active force in the work of loyal love and charity which it has ordained. The tender ceremonies of Memorial Day will then be performed by others or not at all. It seems to me that it would be the part of wisdom for us while yet in our vigor to establish such relationship between our Order and the Sons of Veterans as to properly recognize the organization.

As a result of Commander-in-Chief Rea's presentation the GAR adopted the following resolution.

During the 1890 National Encampment in St. Joseph, Missouri, A.P. Davis recounted the early history of the SUVCW in an interview with a reporter from the St. Joe "Ballot" published on August 25, 1890.

Davis continued,

Augustus concluded his remarks with the following:

A.P. Davis "infant adventure" had indeed been successful. At the time of the 1890 National Encampment he reported the total membership at 145,000. The number would eventually reach it pinnacle of slightly more than 200,000 in 1904.

Throughout the remainder of his life A.P. Davis continued to foster the growth of his beloved Sons and the Ladies Aid Society [later to change its name to Auxiliary to the Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War] which he had founded in 1884. He developed incentive programs for those who recruited new members and traveled extensively promoting the Order.

His health continuing to decline, A.P. Davis was confined to bed by his doctor in the fall of 1898. After a prolonged illness, he answered his final muster call at 6:00 AM May 21, 1899 at his home -- 6335 Howe Street, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

On May 22, 1899, the following notice appeared on page one of the Pittsburgh "Press". A mass meeting of the Sons of Veterans of Pittsburgh, Allegheny and vicinity is called to meet tonight at 7:30 PM in the Armory of CO A, 14th Regiment, in Old City Hall to take suitable action regarding the death of Major Augusts P. Davis. The number of Sons attending the meeting was so great they could not all be accommodated.

On May 24, 1899, Major Augustus Plummer "Father" Davis was laid to rest in Allegheny Cemetery, Pittsburgh. While we do no know the number of Sons who participated in his funeral, we do know it was estimated at several thousand. One report characterized the funeral procession as ...rivaling that of a President of the United States.

At the behest of Mrs. Davis, it was the Sons of Veterans burial service which was conducted. The pall bearers, honor guard, and firing squad were all from his beloved Sons. Even his Comrades of GAR Post 3 conceded that it was more fitting that the Sons conduct the service than they.

Even in death Davis continued to provide for the Sons of Veterans. In his last will and testament he bequeathed $500.00 to the National Organization, $250.00 to the Ladies Aid Society and $50.00 to Davis Camp. He also bequeathed the following personal property to the National Organization:

On March 6, 1902, the Commandery-in-Chief of the Sons of Veterans of the United States declined to accept the $500 legacy. The personal property was accepted.

Regardless of the unsubstantiated allegation about Augustus P. Davis character made by those opposed to his pension, his later life did not give any indication of such behavior. The readers are left to decide for themselves the true character of the man.

Epitaph

Author's Note. Much of the information in this biography was gathered by David B. Orr, Past Department Commander of Pennsylvania and Past National Historian, prior to his death. During the ensuing years additional information has been gathered. The forthcoming 100th anniversary of the death of Augustus Plummer Davis on May 21, 1999 was the impetus to compile the information and write this biography.
Acknowledgments: The assistance of many people was required to assemble all the information needed to write this biography. In addition to David B. Orr, PDC, the author is indebted to Brothers George Randall and John Douglas. PCC of Davis * Camp, Joseph Pulgini, former Director Department of Veterans Services, Allegheny County Pennsylvania, Bruno Krsul, former Director Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall, Pittsburgh, PA, Rozenne Bucher former Liberian Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall for there invaluable assistance and Rebecca Pratt for critically reviewing the manuscript.

References
Minute Books Davis Camp, Department of Pennsylvania, Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Correspondence files Davis Camp, Department of Pennsylvania, Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Minute Books General Alexander Hays Post 3, Department of Pennsylvania, Grand Army of the Republic.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Descriptive Book General Alexander Hays Post 3, Department of Pennsylvania, Grand Army of the Republic.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Pittsburgh "Commercial Gazette" May 22, 1899.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Pittsburgh "Press" May 22, 1899.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Pittsburgh "Press" May 24, 1899.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Last Will and Testament of Augustus Plummer Davis and associated probate records, Registrar of Wills, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.
Last Will and Testament of Nancy Fulton Davis and associated probate records, Registrar of Wills, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.
Death Certificate of A.P. Davis, January 16, 1900 City of Pittsburgh Health Department, Allegheny County Health Department.
City Directory Pittsburgh 1878, 1879, 1880, 1893, 1894, 1896, 1906, 1913.
Pension claim #102297 A. P. Davis. National Archives, Washington, DC.
Military Record A. P. Davis National Archives, Washington, DC.
Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States Registry of Commandery of Pennsylvania from April 15, 1865 to May 5, 1887 pg 105.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall Journal National Encampment Grand Army of the Republic Columbus, Ohio 1888.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall, "History of the Easel Shaped Monument and a Key to the GAR".
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall, St. Joe "Ballot" August 25, 1890.
Archives Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall, Patterson, NJ "Morning Call" September.

© Copyright 1999, Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War,
A Congressionally-Chartered Corporation

Return to Loyal Legion Vignettes Page

Return to MOLLUS Home Page

Return to MOLLUS Web Site Index Page


KGH